In the eleven years of blogging, I occasionally muse about the nature of blogging. When I’m in a (self-) critical mood I refer to it as an extreme form of self-advertisement; in more benign moods I talk about its role in clarifying confused thinking….
And, of course, I’ve noticed that most serious blogs specialise in a particular topic – be it novels; economic, political or legal commentary; the EU; social policy; Marxist economics; a particular academic discipline etc
What I haven’t paid enough attention to is how few serious blogs there are – like this one - which challenge these boundaries and choose to tramp or trespass in what I have called “NO Man’s Land”. The other image I have used is that of the butterfly which gracefully alights for a few moments on a flower and then moves on. I should perhaps be more careful in my use of that image/metaphor since the butterfly’s life is a short one
So in closing, for the moment, this series of “posts…so far this year”, I want to try to identify those few blogs which set their face against being enclosed by boundaries and range more freely.
1. Let me start with someone who has sadly gone silent these past couple of years – a retired Liverpool academic, Gerry of How the Light Gets In whose material makes for great reading - with celebrations of the history and landscapes of NE Engalnd – as well as cultural and literary events all covered in loving detail. Hopefully Gerry will find his voice again…
2. Then a blog from a Bulgarian woman long resident in the US – Maria Popova - whose Brain Pickings focus on the timeless and uplifting advice of creative writers such as Ursula le Guin, Kurt Vonnegut, George Orwell and Rebecca Solnit
3. Then there’s my current favourite blogger, Canadian Dave Pollard of How to Save the World whose blog exudes the integrity of someone searching for what is worthwhile in life and living
4. Another blog which defies classification is RioWang – which is half travelogue (but of such way-out places as Iran and the Caucusus ) and half celebration of the remnants of old Jewish history in such places. This, for example, is the latest post which includes a classic Persian song
5. Brave New Europe is a leftist site with an open and creative selection process
6. The Worthy House is a blog I hesitated to include – since its over-confident, ant-leftist tone sometimes offends me but the sheer range of its reviews warrant its inclusion. See for yourself with these reviews of the important book The Geography of Thought; Banfield’s The Moral Basis of a Backward Society (to which I often refer in the posts); and Graeber’s Bullshit Jobs of which they seem none too fond.
But why can I find only a handful of blogs with such an open spirit?
Posts This Year – Part V – the last few weeks
Post Title |
Inspired by |
The basic message |
A Polish right-wing philosopher
challenges liberal democracy |
Identity politics has indeed gone too
far |
|
A 3 year old article with that title |
is puritanism and post-modernism really
to blame? |
|
Remembering the debate in the 1970s
about “muddling through” |
Did post-modernism and behavioural
economics really start the rot? |
|
A long-overdue Manifesto |
We have become too cynical about
institutions |
|
“Nervous States” book by William Davies |
How did experts initially get their
status – and then lose it so recently? |
|
David Goodhart’s latest book |
The devaluing of manual and technical
work and the overestimation of the university |
|
The accident of genius; how a 1977
report changed the UK |
30 years after Thatcher’s resignation,
we still don’t have the measure of her |
|
Rutger Bregman’s latest book is a model
of clarity |
His argument that humans are basically
altruistic doesn’t quite convince – altho he adds the rider about “power
corrupting” |
|
A reread of Bregman’s book |
One of my famous tables - with 22 of
Bregman’s exploded myths explained |
|
I get fed up hearing the UK PM talk
about “following the science” |
Governments can’t avoid choices and
values. Experts have their limits |
|
2 of my favourite blogs |
The endgame |
|
Reading at last J Michael Greer’s “The
Long Descent” (2008) |
I realise how little I understand about
energy issues |
|
This is the time of the year when I
start to think about the annual E-book of posts |
It is an opportunity to reflect on the
blog’s distinctiveness – and what it might be doing better |
|
Perennials - II |
I like to think that a post of several
years ago can still be read with benefit |
why straddling boundaries gives insights |
A book-length report from a fascinating
new think-tank with teams in 4 countries |
Gives a detailed insight into the UK of
2020 – using the work of psychologist Jonathan Haidt |
|
Le Temps Perdu III |
The third of the series |
Why we should turn off the News |
Between the Lines - IV |
I’ve started – so I’ll finish |
What I would like to be distinctive
about the blog |
Dave Pollard’s blog which, like mine,
is also one of the few generalist blogs |
The importance in these times of good
questions – and of not being put off by the lack of response |
No comments:
Post a Comment