I had no sooner started a
weekly ”Links I Liked” feature than I lost my connection to the blog.
Until then I had dumped any
excerpts of useful material I had found on the internet (with the relevant link)
in a special folder - and extracted only stuff that I knew I was going to use
in a pending blogpost. The result was a file which kept on getting larger but
which I rarely looked at. The ”Links I Liked” feature gave me the incentive to
go back to the folder and put up useful stuff which is easier to find that
rifling through a 200 pages file.....
This past week saw a couple of book reviews
The Boston review is an impressive new find for
me – although their review of Foretelling
the End of Capitalism: Intellectual Misadventures Since Karl Marx by Francesco Boldizzoni was a bit
opaque for my liking. It started well
The first four chapters
move quickly through a series of proficient and deftly connected capsule
summaries of thinkers across a range of fields, from economics to philosophy to
sociology.
Although those who have
spent more time with these authors may occasionally be frustrated by the
glosses of complex arguments, the point is not to cast new light on any one
idea, but to show, through volume and range, the many ways that people have
thought about capitalism’s end, and the many ways they have gotten it wrong:
thus far none of the predictions has proved correct.
And continued with a
typology for which I’m always a sucker –
There are, Boldizzoni
argues, four kinds of predictions.
-
There are
theories of implosion, wherein capitalism collapses because of pressures that
arise from the workings of its own logic.
-
There are
theories of exhaustion, which predict capitalism will “die of natural
causes”—it runs up against environmental limits, or moral advances enable
people to move beyond it.
-
There are
theories of convergence, wherein capitalism and socialism become more and more
alike, appearing as mirror images of modern rationality and bureaucratic
organization.
-
Finally,
there is “cultural involution,” wherein capitalism kills off the non-economic
values that made it work in the first place.
Some of these tendencies
seem more significant than others: theories of implosion, for example, recur
far more frequently than theories of convergence.....
The trouble is that I don’t
know what a ”cultural involution” is when it’s at home! A google query didn’t
really help but it did unearth a real gem of a book I will come to in a moment..
But I liked the sound of the Italian’s book – precisely the combination of
potted intellectual biographies I like
The second review was a critical one of Rutger Bregman’s latest - Human
Nature – a hopeful history - which came out of his previous extraordinarily
well-written Utopia
for Realists (you can see what I mean by clicking the title since it gives
the entire book!)
I also like intellectual history – particularly of countries.
So I loved “How
the French Think” and consider that Perry Anderson’s The
New Old World is one of the most fascinating books I have ever read.
So the website Reading the Chinese Dream is a
real find – thanks to this
review in the New York Review of Books
The web site is
devoted to the subject of intellectual life in contemporary China, and more particularly to the writings of establishment intellectuals. What you will find here are essentially translations of Chinese texts that we consider important, together with discussions of related issues
One of my regrets is that,
despite my best intentions, I haven’t been able to access similar sites about European
debates eg French let alone German. Eurozine
is the only site which gives the occasional glimpse….
European Think Tanks, of
course, are very active and many of them – such as the Rosa Luxemburg
Stiftung – offer bilingual material.
Time was when I was a
great fan of the New Labour Demos Think Tank
- which has become a rather bipartisan outfit these days and, like most
London-based think-tanks, focused on England.
Scotland, after all, has had
its own parliament for 23 years and therefore its own think-tanks – such as Common Weal which as just produced two interesting
documents on Resilience
Economics and Resilient
Scotland
Finally a quite remarkable
book which came to my attention only today as I searched for a definition of
the phrase “cultural involution”. It was published in France in 2004 – before,
that is, the global financial collapse which it anticipates along with the
ecological one - Convergence
of Catastrophes by Guillaume Faye who, on
further investigation, turns out to have been the sort of ultra-right winger with whom France has long been familiar
The English translation
only saw the light of day in 2012 – which says a lot…..
No comments:
Post a Comment