At that stage, of course, I should reread not just to see if it makes sense – but to see if the material could be shortened. It was Alexander Pope apparently whose 19th century poem went –
a celebration of intellectual trespassing by a retired "social scientist" as he tries to make sense of the world..... Gillian Tett puts it rather nicely in her 2021 book “Anthro-Vision” - “We need lateral vision. That is what anthropology can impart: anthro-vision”.
what you get here
Friday, June 21, 2019
“Brevity is the Soul of Wit”
At that stage, of course, I should reread not just to see if it makes sense – but to see if the material could be shortened. It was Alexander Pope apparently whose 19th century poem went –
Wednesday, June 13, 2018
In Praise of the Butterfly
Most serious blogs I glance at have a theme – be it British literature; Marxist Economics; paintings; Brexit; French politics; policy analysis; left politics or…Scottish mountains - which the authors stick to fairly religiously with the only relief being the occasional bit of music…(eg Boffy’s Blog; or All That’s Solid)
Linz and Stepan's Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation (1996) and Elster and Offe's Rebuilding the Ship at Sea - Institutional Design in post-communist Countries (1997) were subsequently the bibles for transitilogy.....
I had started at an early age this rather odd habit of writing (and publishing) papers and article trying to make sense of the experience – which I have continued for coming up for half a century.
Sunday, April 14, 2019
A Musing Decade
This is an experiment – and I hope you will not be too confused by the variety of titles you will find popping up in the next few weeks..
Although I was delighted when the monthly click rate rose a couple of years ago to 10,000, it has reached those dizzy heights on only 3 occasions and is currently running at half that level. I consider the blog an amazing “resource” (I will come back to that word) – on issues ranging from Brexit, administrative reform, Bulgarian and Romanian culture, Germany, the 2014 Scottish Referendum, the state (see the E-books in the top right column of the blog). But neither the word "Balkan" nor "Carpathian" are keywords people use when they are googling on these subjects.....And the name indeed gives a false impression.... So I reckon the blog needs a name which better expresses its content and objectives
I realise, of course, that the way to increase the profile of a blog or website is to manipulate the algorithms – but this costs money I’m not willing to pay…
Let’s be clear, I’m not interested in raising the profile as an end in itself…..I have no illusions about my significance. But I am confident that my blog (and website) is an almost unique “resource” or, if you prefer, “library”..Not of my writing – but of the insights of others whose books and papers I’ve taken the time and trouble to seek out and whose significance I have the capacity to recognize and want to pass on……
But what exactly, I hear you ask, do I mean when I say the blog is one of the longest-running “of its “kind”? Simply that the majority of blogs specialize in a particular topic - whether EC Law, literary reviews (a popular subject), economics (ditto) or Marxist economics – more popular than you think eg Michael Robert’s or Boffy’s Blog (going since 2007) which interrupts its Marxist exegesis with comment on British politics)
Mine darts like a butterfly to a variety of flowers as I tried to explain in a post last year in the blog’s 2018 Annual – The Search for the Holy Grail. I indeed tried to argue that my claim for the reader’s attention is based on –
Wednesday, January 5, 2022
Patterns of the Mind
Some 18 months ago I noticed a strange omission in the blog – no discussion of climate change. Rather lamely, I tried to explain this blog silence by suggesting that
- the issue was too
complex;
- others were dealing with
it;
- technical change would
sort things out; or
- a few personal changes in life-style could at least salve the conscience….
What’s strange is that I do buy, download and read books on the subject. It’s just that I don’t choose to share the content with readers of the blog. Why not? I wonder…
Last year, I did
have two posts on the issue – the first on the Extinction Movement whoseprotests in
the UK have brought forward new laws there which are seen in liberal circles as
threatening the very essence of English identity.
The other consisted of my initial notes on a book which had just been published Commanding Hope - the power we have to renew a world in peril (2020) by Thomas Homer-Dixon and which I recognised as deserving of a reread. As always, I got distracted and it took a reminder from the author himself a couple of days ago to direct me back to the book
What had originally
intrigued me about Dixon’s book was its focus on our mental processes – on the mix of hope and despair we brought to a
subject which can and does arouse trauma. At the time I was aware only of geographer Mike Hulme’s Why We Disagree about
Climate Change – understanding controversy, inaction and opportunity” (2009) - although Clive
Hamilton had apparently produced Requiem for a species – why we resist the truth
about climate change in
2010.
My reread of Homer-Dixon’s latest alerted me to two other useful titles on this intriguing theme of why most of us seem unable to take the issue of global warming with the seriousness which it warrants – Living in Denial: Climate Change, Emotions, and Everyday Life; Kari Marie Norgaard (2011) and Don’t Even Think About It: Why Our Brains Are Wired to Ignore Climate Change ; George Marshall (2014)
Although it’s only a year since I
first read “Commanding Hope”, the reread didn’t ring any bells in my head; and
that’s despite my having made notes available in the last half of
the post - which
questioned the lack of an index and bibliography. Many of you may see this as a
bit pedantic of me – but, if I’m
spending a few hours reading an author’s work I need to have a sense of their
biases. I don’t need (or even want) a long reading list - indeed the
shorter the better since the author is then required to think very carefully
about the average reader. A reading list stretching over 40 pages is simply a
virility symbol – “see how clever I am”!!
I do find it disturbing, however, that I have so little recollection of reading the book – just 12 months ago. That’s not a good sign!
Rightly in my view the book identifies “world views” as a crucial factor in explaining the attitude we adopt to global warming. Coincidentally, I devoted a section of Voices in the Air – the 2021 posts (just uploaded to the blog) to that very subject (from p 105) in which I make the point that the term is only one of five you can find in the literature – others being “world values”, “political culture”, “cultural theory” and “cultural values”. Homer-Dixon makes my life more complicated by offering two more terms – “cognitive affective maps” and something he calls “ideological state space” which he explains in a table containing 15 fundamental “issues” which divide people such as
Are moral principles universal and
objective?
is the world a safe or a dangerous
place?
Is the world best understood
through reason or emotion?
Can people choose their fate?
Are there large and essential
differences between groups of people?
How much should we care about other
people?
Should one resist authority or
defer to it?
I’m not able to reproduce the table so can’t do justice to it here. Those interested can read this 40 page article which Homer-Dixon wrote in 2015 and which reproduces an earlier version of the table and all the diagrams. He has also outlined his "theory of hope" in this useful briefing note.
Thursday, December 10, 2009
a day's reading
I vowed to do a blog each day – partly to encourage the tiny readership I have but also because it is an important discipline – writing is more challenging than talking – it reveals the gaps in your logic and information. And I’ve found it salutary to put on record some of the discoveries which give life its daily delight. And, when you’re a bookish sort of person, that will include insights gained from books. That indeed is one of the main purpose of the blog – to share useful references in the field in which I’ve chosen to spend so much of my life.
Anyway, I have failed to deliver on my daily quota – mainly because I was going through one of these phases of disgust with reading. I was bloated! Books and work – a life not quite in balance? More of that, perhaps, in another post. In the meantime I simply have to admire those such as Matthew Taylor (see links) who are able to make regular posts – with helpful references to the writings of others. One of features I admire in Matthew’s blogs is the honesty with which he confesses his self-doubts. There are millions of us “symbolic analysts” (as Robert Reich memorably called us) who spend our lives scribbling and meeting in ways which our ancestors would find shocking – and being well paid for it. No wonder that the angst sometime shows through!
OK enough of the guilt. What have I found in recent days which is worth sharing? My focus at the moment is a rather challenging assignment in China. Subject to final medical and visa clearance, I depart in 5 weeks and have now started to think myself into the task. I have first to prepare a “Baseline study” on the state of public administration reform there – imagine!! And, as part of that, to draft various briefing papers on the lessons from the countless initiatives of European states in this area eg performance and quality management.
I want to hit the ground running as far as the second part of the initial work is concerned and am therefore trying to first to track down as many recent assessments on the European experience as I can. I do my best to keep up to date – but it is only in the break between assignments that I have to do the surfing and reading which is needed. Earlier this year, for example, I discovered that I had missed quite a few key documents from the British Cabinet Office and yesterday I came across some interesting reports which the National Audit Office had commissioned from academics on innovation in the public sector. I’ve not been able to get separate internet references for the various documents but punch “innovation government” in the NAO search engine and you’ll get 3-4 interesting papers . The NAO also commissioned PWC to do a review of “Good Government” which focuses on France and USA.
The Cabinet Office has also published a useful study of what they regard as good government initiatives here
“Innovation”, “good government”, “improvement”, quality management”, “performance management” etc The language itself confuses – and, to some post-modernists, is itself the product. I hope to return to this issue which is referred to by the academics who have made this their specialism eg Boivard, Brouckaert, Loeffler, Peters, Pollitt. The European Group of Public Administration has lhad a special committee exploring the issue of productivity in the public sector for some years. Their papers can be accessed here You can see why I had no time yesterday to blog – I was too busy surfing!
I also came across an interesting overview from 2004 by Elaine KamarckShe made some intriguing references to the work of President Vincente Fox of Mexico (2000-2006) and when I googled this item I was referred to an article in an open electronic journal I had forgotten about – The International Public Management Review. A glance at the article on the Mexican experience of reform (by Dusaugge) persuaded me that their experience is very relevant to the Chinese! Read it for yourself at And today, I discovered the Scandinavian Journal of Politics – whose articles I am able to access courtesy of Wiley. Some fascinating accounts of what they’ve been up to which rarely get to the mainstream journals. Sorry I’m not able to share them – I’ll try to summarise at some point in the future.
Friday, April 26, 2019
Six Questions about the new draft
Tuesday, November 3, 2015
"What am I good at/for?" - a SWOT approach
I am confused as to what I might usefully do with my life. I suppose the question I have been pondering is, what good am I?
- So, in 2009, I started this blog and also a website with some of my papers with no less a purpose than leaving behind a record of how one 20th century man thought of the world he had been lucky enough to experience……
- At one stage I became so desperate about the rise of corporate greed that I actually contemplated launching the idea of a geriatric kamikaze mission to target the financial class - on the Mintzberg argument that the vanishing "people power" of trade unions and voters needed some strengthening to ensure the "rebalancing of society". But I quickly realised that this would merely further strengthen the repressive power of the "security state" which has replaced our mixed economies and liberal democracies....
- The results of broad and deep reading over 50 years about social science matters
- The practice of thinking out aloud since 1970 - in short papers about the work in which I was involved (see “lessons learned” on the new website for those from the past 20 years; “E-books” for almost a dozen of that genre)
- More than 1000 mini-essays with almost 10,000 hyperlinks – on the blog Balkan and Carpathian Musings
- the results of pretty intensive net-surfing for relevant writing over the past decade -available in Mapping the Common Ground’s library
Friday, October 23, 2020
The 2020 posts …..so far
The blog marked its 1,500th post at the beginning of the month – over eleven years. That’s almost 3 posts a week. To celebrate I’ve uploaded the posts for 2020 (86 so far) into a little E-book of some 200 pages which you can find here
I realise this may be a bit daunting for you – so here is the first instalment of a little series I’m offering to entice you into the riches….. I use that word only half-mockingly since the key feature this blog offers is the depth of the hyperlinks it offers into articles and books on important subjects…. It takes the form of one of the tables which have become one of the blog’s distinguishing features – with
- the first
column being the title of a post - to access, just click
-
the
second column, trying to identify the event which was the catalyst to the post
- the final column ,the basic message I would like to think the post should leave with the reader
The E-book itself starts with an explanation first of the benefits blogging offers; then of why I, in particular, continue to find it a useful self-discipline for almost every morning; and finally why, for the past year, the blog operates with this particular title…..
The Posts so Far in 2020…..
Title |
What sparked it off |
The “takeaway” or basic
message |
To
whom it may concern - the 2019 posts |
Pride in my
posts of the previous year |
Tables have become an important self-discipline |
Poetry? Maybe |
An Adrian Mitchell poem |
“Most people ignore most poetry - Because - Most poetry ignores most people” |
Discovering that posts about capitalism were the 2019 posts‘
second favourite topic |
Most interesting narratives are from Collier, Hirschmann,
Mander, Varoufakis |
|
|
And that few economists could properly explain the global financial
crash |
My “Dispatches to the Next Generation” identifies more than
200 key books and then
whittles that down to 50 or so key texts |
exploring why my fixation about this issue is actually
increasing |
Events in
2020 have demonstrated how much we have neglected the importance of “the
state” in the past 30 years |
|
The matrix that resulted from an “ideological triangulation” of a dozen
academic disciplines |
We need to be more
aware of the ideological lens authors are using (often without their own
appreciation) |
|
The further thoughts that led me into |
It’s been in the air most of us still alive have breathed;
we don’t really think about it – nor care….. |
|
A useful January
exercise |
We like to feel, flick and smell the pages of real books |
|
A great little book called “The Econocracy” with this
warning as a sub-title |
Economics is a religion – and needs more pluralism and
sceptics |
|
The leaving of the EU on Jan 31st – Brexit being
this blog’s most frequent topic during 2019 |
To my horror I find that a “Daily Telegraph” article has
read my thoughts |
|
A Dutch friend’s farewell letter |
I didn’t do justice to the LEXIT arguments |
|
An episode of “The Crown” takes me back to the 1960s and
suspicions about a British PM being a Moscow mole |
The continuing post-mortem on the British suicide mission |
|
A superb satire
on the british system |
Anthony Jay put it all so well in 1989 |
|
Frustration with Dropbox |
See the E-books listed in the top-right corner of the blog |
|
many significant hyperlinks never see the light of day |
I share my morning routines |